The Scalps That Never Were
S01:E42

The Scalps That Never Were

•

Episode description

My grandparents came home from Simcoe, Ontario, with a story that the Collvers had once scalped people: the "Cutthroat Collvers." The story is real. It began on the eighth of July, 1794, as one anonymous paragraph in a Rutland, Vermont, newspaper claiming that Governor Simcoe paid a guinea apiece for American scalps, and it travelled by reprint to New Hampshire, North Carolina, Philadelphia, and at last The Times of London.

This episode follows the rumor from paper to paper, sets it beside the summer the Reverend Jabez Collver's family moved into Simcoe's province, and shows how a governor's name, a town's name, and a hundred years turned American propaganda into a family legend. It closes with the other half of the kitchen-table story, the 1912 monument at Old Windham.

Text, sources, and notes at history.collver.biz.

No transcript available for this episode.